Wednesday, January 10, 2007

A good education is a lottery!

In seeking to broaden the "social inclusiveness" of good schools by selecting pupils by lottery rather than by catchment area, Labour will only achieve three things:

  • The destruction of said good schools as standards will be diluted over time as good teachers keen to work at good schools leave the profession.
  • The destruction of any remaining support amongst middle class parents or aspirational working class parents for Labour. How many families will be prepared to sacrifice a £25,000 property premium for living within the catchment area of a good school?
  • Social mobility will continue it's decline as the premium for being privately educated at a good school can only increase further.


  • Labour needs to consider whether the middle classes squeeze low income families out of good schools or if that's why the schools are good!

    2 comments:

    chris said...

    With the housing market the way it is at the moment wiping £25,000 off the value of thousands of homes nation wide could easily cause a recession.

    Snafu said...

    Chris, why should a reduction in wealth of £25k lead to a recession especially when it's a paper gain for many people? Further increases in interest rates are more likely to lead to recession.